• ECCE
  • School Edu
  • Higher Edu
  • Edu Tech
  • Skills
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Login
[t4b-ticker]
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Spotlight
  • Perspective
  • Interview
  • Videos
  • Events
  • Shop
  • Student Kiosk
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Spotlight
  • Perspective
  • Interview
  • Videos
  • Events
  • Shop
  • Student Kiosk
No Result
View All Result
Education21
Home Latest

Schools’ surge in marketing to attract pupils fuels inequalities globally, new research reveals

A pioneering global study has revealed how schools worldwide are using a raft of marketing techniques to attract higher performing pupils and climb the league tables

education by education
February 16, 2023
in Latest, School Edu
0
Schools’ surge in marketing to attract pupils fuels inequalities globally, new research reveals
0
SHARES
25
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The research, published on Feb 16 and led by the University of Bristol, shows how the increasing trend of parents being able to choose which primary and secondary school their child goes to has resulted in greater rivalry, driving an industry of marketing activity in both public and paid-for schools, sometimes at the expense of improvements to education.

A team of marketing, policy and economics experts set to analysing all the published evidence available. This involved reviewing dozens of research papers about the marketing practices of primary and secondary schools, studying data from 16 countries, including the UK, America, Canada, Australia, and Taiwan.

The findings uncovered a prevalence of concerning practices, such as targeting certain households to boost academic performance and using misleading imagery in promotional materials. Marketing through the careful management of information presented to parents is being used as a quicker more cost-effective substitute for real academic and operational changes. There were also instances of pupil recruitment taking priority over the quality of teaching in the US and Australia, where teachers were actively involved in community outreach events, canvassing and social media campaigns.

The report therefore calls for further research into the nature and impact of school marketing combined with much-needed regulatory reform to ensure such methods support equitable access to better education.

Corresponding author Agnes Nairn, Professor of Marketing at the University of Bristol Business School and Pro Vice-Chancellor for Global Engagement, said: “The full extent of school marketing and what forms it takes has largely fallen under the radar . This is the first-ever systematic review of all studies and the findings are rather worrying.

“Instead of raising their game and making tangible improvements, which can be costly, riskier and take more time, schools all over the world are deploying various marketing methods to attract pupils. Worse still, we discovered evidence of this activity being exploited to in effect exclude disadvantaged children deemed less likely to be high academic achievers and more troublesome to teach. Rather than helping to level up performance and reduce social inequality, marketing practices induced by school choice programmes inadvertently exacerbate these issues.”

Ironically, the report findings suggest schools with the most to legitimately shout about were less active with marketing because they are often fully subscribed. Meanwhile, schools performing poorly in the league tables have a greater incentive to go into marketing overdrive to attract enough pupils to stay open.

Many of the research papers criticised the usage of imagery and words in publicity material, observing that rhetoric, unverified claims, and specific imagery were deployed to enhance the school’s reputation and appeal to different social classes.

First author Dr Ellen Greaves, Max Weber Fellow at the European University Institute in Italy, said: “Choosing a school is an important and difficult decision for parents. Schools’ current marketing practices are unlikely to help parents in this process, as they often provide only unsubstantiated or unverifiable claims. This includes explicit and implicit assertions about the educational performance and pupil composition of the school.”

The report also identified a growing body of research demonstrating how techniques such as market segmentation and targeting were being routinely used to screen, select, and exclude prospective students. In the US, households in affluent Downtown areas were favoured over those from remote neighbourhoods, thereby worsening social and racial segregation. For example, a recent study of some 6,500 schools operating under choice-based systems in the US revealed application information was provided selectively, with schools being less responsive to enquiries from students regarded as harder to teach or from certain nationalities.

Activity to target pupils perceived as easier to teach and more likely to get higher grades was also found in the UK.

Co-author Professor Deborah Wilson, Dean of the Faculty of Humanities & Social Sciences at the University of Bath, said: “Targeting marketing in particular neighbourhoods or to types of parents is a form of covert selection by schools. Covert selection has been banned during the school admissions process in England, but not during schools’ marketing campaigns.

“Evidence from around the world suggests that schools in many contexts have an incentive to recruit certain types of pupils, and that marketing currently remains a legitimate way to do this. Policymakers and regulators need to find a way to help schools focus on improving the quality of education they provide, rather than the quality of their marketing campaigns.”

In Taiwan, the level of competition between schools was so intense it has led to unethical, even illegal, practices such as bribery of teachers at feeder schools, who would serve as publicity tools, to recruit top performing pupils.

Given the total current lack of marketing regulations for schools globally, the report urges the International Chamber of Commerce to intervene and kickstart a process of reform to help combat widespread bad practice.

Prof Nairn said: “Marketing and advertising regulations in this area are much overdue as it is clear that false and exclusionary marketing practices are taking place. Clear measures must be introduced so parents and pupils are protected, and to help reverse the social injustices this activity has further entrenched.”

Paper

‘Marketing and school choice: a systematic literature review’ by Greaves et al. in Review of Education Research

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed
Previous Post

Applications open for OMEDK- Uni-GAUGE Entrance Exam for UGET 2023

Next Post

Former Edu Secy Anita Karwal’s book ‘The Power of Curiosity—in and beyond classrooms’ to hit stores in June

education

education

Related Posts

Arduino launches the Innovation & Learning Hub (AILH) at Manav Rachna, Faridabad
Higher Edu

Arduino launches the Innovation & Learning Hub (AILH) at Manav Rachna, Faridabad

by education
August 29, 2025
Witty International School Borivali’s ‘No-Fire Modak Workshop’ adds to innovative Ganesh Chaturthi Celebrations
School Edu

Witty International School Borivali’s ‘No-Fire Modak Workshop’ adds to innovative Ganesh Chaturthi Celebrations

by education
August 29, 2025
The Himalayan School announces hybrid campus in Bahrain
School Edu

The Himalayan School announces hybrid campus in Bahrain

by education
August 29, 2025
Sri Sri Ravishankar Vidya Mandir Students duo win TCS InQuizitive 2025 Bengaluru Edition
School Edu

Sri Sri Ravishankar Vidya Mandir Students duo win TCS InQuizitive 2025 Bengaluru Edition

by education
August 29, 2025
Harish & Bina Shah Foundation (HBSF) Commits ₹100 Crores to Advance Girls’ Education in India with Educate Girls
School Edu

Harish & Bina Shah Foundation (HBSF) Commits ₹100 Crores to Advance Girls’ Education in India with Educate Girls

by education
August 28, 2025
Next Post
Former Edu Secy Anita Karwal’s book ‘The Power of Curiosity—in and beyond classrooms’ to hit stores in June

Former Edu Secy Anita Karwal’s book ‘The Power of Curiosity—in and beyond classrooms’ to hit stores in June

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed

Useful Announcements

  • All
  • Useful Announcements

IIM Indore announces the launch of 9th batch of Executive Certificate Programme in Strategy and Leadership

August 29, 2025

JD’s launch two new Digital Design UG and 3- one-year Diploma Programs

August 28, 2025

HCLTech, Pearson India and MeitY Startup Hub launch ARISE FOR YOU™ aimed at igniting the entrepreneurial spirit among India’s youth

August 28, 2025

Ayurveda Day to be marked on 23 September annually from 2025

August 26, 2025
India to Celebrate National Sports Day 2025 as Three-Day Fitness Festival

India to Celebrate National Sports Day 2025 as Three-Day Fitness Festival

August 25, 2025

Ministry of Youth Affairs & Sports invites nominations for National Youth Award 2024 by Sep 30

August 25, 2025

Choose France Tour 2025 to Showcase World-Class Education Opportunities for Indian Students

August 25, 2025

IIT Delhi Launches Online PG Diploma in EV Technology

August 25, 2025

Green Gold Animation Launches Writer Hunt to Build India’s Next Big Kids’ Animation IP

August 22, 2025

IIHMR Startups to host 3rd Edition of TEDxIIHMRU on Aug 29

August 20, 2025

Download current issue Not available

https://online.pubhtml5.com/jlyo/bxvr/

Monthly Magazine : Feb 2024

Interactive (Quizzes/Surveys)

Start Monthly Quiz
Education21

An initiative in continuation of Curriculum Magazine, Education21.in, is a platform for New India that aspires to be a valuable innovator, partner and collaborator for a just and sustainable world. Continuing with our steady and 360 degree coverage of education system and skills landscape, we are here more oriented towards learner community.

Useful Links

  • About us
  • Team
  • Contact
  • Editorial opportunities
  • Subscriptions
  • Job Opportunities
  • Features

Important Links

  • Blog
  • Archives
  • People
  • Careerwise
  • Resources
  • Downloadable
  • Old issues

Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed

Copyright © 2020 All rights reserved. Education21.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Spotlight
  • Perspective
  • Interview
  • Videos
  • Events
  • Shop
  • Student Kiosk

Copyright © 2020 All rights reserved. Education21.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In