• ECCE
  • School Edu
  • Higher Edu
  • Edu Tech
  • Skills
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Login
[t4b-ticker]
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Spotlight
  • Perspective
  • Interview
  • Videos
  • Events
  • Shop
  • Student Kiosk
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Spotlight
  • Perspective
  • Interview
  • Videos
  • Events
  • Shop
  • Student Kiosk
No Result
View All Result
Education21
Home Opinion

Supreme Court’s Rebuke Over Class 8 Judiciary Chapter Must Be a Lesson for NCERT

education by education
March 12, 2026
in Opinion, School Edu
0
Supreme Court’s Rebuke Over Class 8 Judiciary Chapter Must Be a Lesson for NCERT
0
SHARES
167
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Supreme Court of India’s strong objection to the portrayal of the judiciary in the new Class 8 Social Science textbook published by the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT)—under a chapter titled “The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society”—amounts to a stern message to the academic body: you have been casual in your approach to work and must “stop polluting young minds”. The urgency shown and the sharp words used by the top court should themselves be read as a commentary on the not-so-diligent book-writing culture within the country’s premier school education academic body.

First, a brief context of the controversy. NCERT periodically revises school textbooks to align them with changes in the curriculum. The same process led to the publication of the new Class 8 Social Science textbook Exploring Society: India and Beyond. After releasing Part 1 earlier as part of curriculum changes aligned with the new education framework in July 2025, NCERT brought out Part 2 on February 23, 2026.

Chapter 4 of the book, titled “The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society”, included a discussion on corruption in parts of the judiciary, the shortage of judges, and the massive backlog of cases in courts. The book reached bookstores on February 24, and within no time the issue snowballed into a controversy. Senior lawyers brought the matter to the attention of the Supreme Court, arguing that the chapter amounted to a calculated attempt to malign the judiciary and expose young students to a biased narrative.

The judges observed that the chapter highlighted only the negative aspects of the judiciary while ignoring its vital contributions. “The content is bound to travel from teachers to students to parents to society…the chapter has no mention of the good work done by the judiciary—protection of rights, streamlining access to justice, legal aid, and safeguarding fundamental rights,” the Bench noted. The chapter also gave the impression that complaints against judges were ignored, as though there were no transparency or accountability mechanisms within the judiciary.

A Bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant took suo motu cognizance of the issue and criticised the chapter for presenting the judiciary negatively to school students. Following the court’s intervention, the Ministry of Education, Government of India directed NCERT to halt the distribution of the book—both physical and digital copies. NCERT subsequently admitted that the chapter contained “inappropriate textual material” and announced that it would be rewritten.

The Director of NCERT, Dinesh Prasad Saklani, submitted an affidavit tendering an “unconditional and unqualified apology” for the controversial chapter. NCERT acknowledged that the textbook contained inappropriate material and confirmed that the entire book had been withdrawn from circulation. It assured the court that the chapter would be rewritten before the next academic session.

An additional affidavit was filed by the Secretary of the Department of School Education and Literacy, Sanjay Kumar under the Ministry of Education. It also tendered an unconditional apology and assured the court that systemic safeguards would be introduced to prevent such lapses in the future. During the hearing, the Centre’s law officer informed the court that the government deeply regretted the incident, accepted responsibility, and had initiated corrective measures.

However, the Court remained dissatisfied. It directed NCERT to exclude three experts—Michel Danino, educator Suparna Diwakar, and legal researcher Alok Prasanna Kumar—from any role in preparing school curricula or holding positions in state bodies, citing their association with the controversial chapter.

The top court also directed the Union government to constitute a committee of domain experts to review such matters. The panel will include a former judge, an educationist, and a senior legal expert. The Bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant also took exception to NCERT’s affidavit stating that the controversial chapter had already been rewritten. The court clarified that even a revised chapter cannot be included in the curriculum without approval from the committee of domain experts to be constituted by the Central government.

Commenting on the existing review mechanism, the court remarked that it was “slightly disappointing” that not a single eminent jurist was part of the current approval committee. It directed that any revised chapter must be cleared by a panel comprising one former senior judge, one eminent academician, and one renowned practitioner.

At present, a 19-member National Syllabus and Teaching Learning Material Committee (NSTC), headed by Mahesh Chandra Pant, Chancellor of the National Institute of Educational Planning and Administration (NIEPA), is responsible for approving textbook content and syllabus.

While exposing students to institutional conflicts can help them understand democracy, and debates about judicial power can illustrate the system of checks and balances, equal care must be taken to ensure age-appropriate content. For impressionable young minds, the emphasis should remain on the fundamentals and the constitutional role of the judiciary rather than on complex institutional criticism.

The widespread attention NCERT’s work has drawn because of the Supreme Court’s sharp rap should now galvanise the institution to raise its standards and apply greater diligence to every subject domain and every textbook it publishes. If such lapses could occur in a field scrutinised so closely by legal experts, one wonders whether similar shortcomings may exist in other areas where such scrutiny is absent. NCERT must use this moment to reclaim the academic rigour and credibility that once defined it.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed
Previous Post

EU Co-Funded Erasmus+ NSIS Project to Launch 10-Module Digital Research and Entrepreneurship Training for Universities Across India, Sri Lanka and Nepal

Next Post

12th edition of the Study UK Alumni Awards 2026 in India presented in 4 categories

education

education

Related Posts

Maharashtra organizes Maharashtra Bal Sansad 2026 on World Children’s Day in Pune
School Edu

Maharashtra organizes Maharashtra Bal Sansad 2026 on World Children’s Day in Pune

by education
November 20, 2026
Give parents access and strengthen child safety mechanisms: Priyank Kanoongo
School Edu

Give parents access and strengthen child safety mechanisms: Priyank Kanoongo

by education
November 20, 2026
Delhi launches Ehsaas 2026 to make mental health an integral part of education
Higher Edu

Delhi launches Ehsaas 2026 to make mental health an integral part of education

by education
November 20, 2026
30,000 tablets distributed under the Swami Vivekananda Yuva Sashaktikaran Yojana in UP by LAVA
School Edu

30,000 tablets distributed under the Swami Vivekananda Yuva Sashaktikaran Yojana in UP by LAVA

by education
November 18, 2026
Marico unveils Nihar Shanti Mazbooti Ki Paathshala, a renewed identity for its flagship CSR education initiative
School Edu

Marico unveils Nihar Shanti Mazbooti Ki Paathshala, a renewed identity for its flagship CSR education initiative

by education
November 13, 2026
Next Post
12th edition of the Study UK Alumni Awards 2026 in India presented in 4 categories

12th edition of the Study UK Alumni Awards 2026 in India presented in 4 categories

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed

Useful Announcements

  • All
  • Useful Announcements

Shiv Nadar School student releases documentary inspired by his autistic brother

November 22, 2026

NGO Brain Bristle announces audition of autistic and neurotypical actors aged 16 to 22 for its new play

November 22, 2026

TIET to host the Annual Techno-Cultural Festival ‘Saturnalia 2026’ from November 21–23

November 20, 2026

Eurogrip Tyres Invites Students and Creators to Participate in Torq Challenge 4.0 and Creator Challenge

November 18, 2026

DIDAC India & DIDAC Skills 2026 being held at the Bangalore International Exhibition Centre (BIEC), Bengaluru from 25–27 November

November 18, 2026
EY report on India’s Music Economy calls for stronger creator education and transparency

Accenture LearnVantage and Google Cloud to Bring AI Learning to More Than 1,000 Schools and Colleges in India

November 17, 2026

Target Learning Ventures Launches ‘Bhavna vs Boards’ Campaign

November 17, 2026

Former CJI, Dr. Justice D. Y. Chandrachud to deliver Memorial Lecture at SAI International Education Group

November 17, 2026

Sheffield Hallam University invites applications for MSc Physiotherapy for January 2027 intake

November 16, 2026

Ashoka University Opens 2027 Undergraduate Admissions, Offers 500 Scholarships

November 16, 2026

Download current issue Not available

https://online.pubhtml5.com/jlyo/bxvr/

Monthly Magazine : Feb 2024

Interactive (Quizzes/Surveys)

Start Monthly Quiz
Education21

An initiative in continuation of Curriculum Magazine, Education21.in, is a platform for New India that aspires to be a valuable innovator, partner and collaborator for a just and sustainable world. Continuing with our steady and 360 degree coverage of education system and skills landscape, we are here more oriented towards learner community.

Useful Links

  • About us
  • Team
  • Contact
  • Editorial opportunities
  • Subscriptions
  • Job Opportunities
  • Features

Important Links

  • Blog
  • Archives
  • People
  • Careerwise
  • Resources
  • Downloadable
  • Old issues

Newsletter

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed

Copyright © 2020 All rights reserved. Education21.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Spotlight
  • Perspective
  • Interview
  • Videos
  • Events
  • Shop
  • Student Kiosk

Copyright © 2020 All rights reserved. Education21.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Cleantalk Pixel